How do you know if printer cartridge is faulty as far as fit? -

4in1 HP. Replaced black cartridge. Error message on little screen saying to take out and replace. Did so and carriage started sliding back and forth nonstop hitting the sides of the machine quite hard. Error message on screen then garbled. Prior the screen said paper jam, but there was none. Machine only a few months old. No help in manual!

take your machine back to your dealer or PC store. Hope it still have warranty in it.